Did you know that one of my essays is going to be in a book? I know, I’m shocked, too! The book is Primal Picnics by Whole World Press and it’s an anthology of completely made-up myths about food. Also included is an essay by popular FotF guest poster Barry Foy of Devil’s Food Dictionary fame, as well as some other talented writers and poets. Anyway, it should be a good read, so I’ll let you know when it hits shelves this spring so you can check it out. In the meantime, here is a much-condensed, unedited taste of what to expect from my contribution, which is to say the usual foolishness.
Indian Pudding: A History
It has long been assumed that Indian pudding is made from 100% pure Indians. Not so. In fact, the residents of New Delhi recently won a class-action lawsuit to strike their name from Yankee recipes and pudding-related literature (retroactive to the year 1620), since they have no idea how they ended up as the main ingredient in the first place.
The origins of this sweet and sloppy corn-based dessert have been hotly disputed by modern food historians and chefs alike. Most agree that it originated in America, not India. The native peoples of the New World had been cultivating corn for thousands of years before the Europeans arrived, and anthropological evidence supports that they regularly supplemented their hunter/gatherer diet with some iteration of mushy maize. But some give the credit for what we have come to know as Indian pudding to the British settlers, invoking its striking resemblance to English hasty pudding. Except for the rather obvious presence of corn.
In order to make pudding, you see, you need some kind of starch. Lacking the traditional wheat and on the brink of starvation, the settlers, who believed corn to be food fit only for livestock, eventually had to “settle” for cornmeal (hence, their name). Each night, the British solemnly prayed for deliverance from the evil pangs of hunger that drew them to loiter pathetically at the outskirts of the native villages, stomachs rumbling like drums. The ever-patient Native Americans, sick and tired of finding their corn crop hacked to pieces in the night, finally decided to teach the colonists how to grow their own corn.
Native 1: Like that, okay. Now, leave us alone.
Colonist 1: But, these plants take up so much space. We’re going to need to cut some trees down.Native 1: Keep the trees. Don’t eat so much.
Colonist 1: But, I’m hungry.
Native 1: Eat other things. One can’t live on corn alone.
Colonist 1: Not now, perhaps. But maybe one fine day…
Armed with the secrets to corn cultivation (sun, water), the British got right to work on recipe development. Step 1: Mask the corn flavor. Cinnamon and ginger were added with little Puritanical restraint, as well as imported molasses to sweeten things up (for the kids, they insisted). The Native Americans, realizing their tactical error, got busy making some improvements of their own—namely, the addition of local, sustainably tapped maple syrup.
A vicious game of one-upmanship ensued. New toppings were rolled out. Cook-offs were scheduled, then abruptly cancelled due to plagues/scalpings. Mothers on both sides were hypothetically but very colorfully disrespected. Finally, an emergency meeting was called to settle the most pressing issue: who would get the credit for inventing this distinctly American dish. The honorable tribal leader, Weeps with Great Fury, spoke on behalf of the native peoples, with smooth-talking settler, Manny F. Destiny, representing the colonists’ interests.
Manny: So, we want the pudding.
(Loooong pause)
Manny: That’s our final offer.
Weeps: Offer rejected.
Manny: Okay, okay. Tell me what it would take for us to walk away with the pudding.
Weeps: That’s our corn you’re using. You call it ‘Indian meal,’ though we call it ‘Divine Grain Graced to Us By the Earth in Times of Good Health and Providence.’
Manny: It’s not like you invented corn. We can grow it, too.
Weeps: That’s not what you said last year.
Manny: How about now? Can we have the pudding now?
Weeps: You need to offer something in return.
Manny: Fine. How about some blankets?
Weeps: We’re not cold.
Manny: Trinkets?
Weeps: They are very shiny. But, not shiny enough for pudding. You can have pemmican.
Manny: Pemmican? What’s that?
Weeps: Dried meat and berries.
Manny: …(dry heaves)
Weeps: It’s good for long journeys…
Manny: I think we might be here for a while.
It went back and forth like this for quite some time, and the two parties seemed to be at an impasse. Finally, Manny offered up the following compromise:
Manny: How about this? One of us gets this land, and the other gets the pudding.
Weeps: One cannot possess the land. The land possesses us.
Manny: So…if the earth decided to “possess” us and not you, then you would get the pudding. And if the earth “possessed” you, then we would get the pudding.
Weeps: If you get the pudding, you will leave?
Manny: Yes. But we retain all print and electronic rights to Indian pudding from now until infinity in all media yet to be invented.
The natives consult briefly.
Weeps: We accept. The earth will decide. She always chooses correctly. And as a gesture of goodwill, we present you with pemmican for your travels.
Manny: Mmmmmm…(gagging). Chewy. And for you, some trinkets. I’ll even wrap them up for you in this nice, warm blanket.
The rest, as they say, is history. The colonists stayed. Never trust the earth. At least the British kept their word and relinquished all claims of pudding authorship. If only the U.S. copyright office had gotten the name right.



